[ It's a slight relief that he's at least willing to go along with this, but the whole door situation really feels like only the first hurdle on a gigantic mountain to climb. ]

Alright, then on to the next ridiculous sounding part. You're also from the other side of that door. I'm not sure why you don't remember it, or.. whatever this place is.

[ Other than "weird" and "kind of creepy", anyway. ]

That's how I know you. We talked a lot before. It's not like we're best friends, but.. you know. [ A vague hand gesture. ] We talked. I know you're not actually as old as you look right now, if that helps to prove it.