[Honestly, he wasn't expecting to be comforted at all, and he's really not sure what to do with the sudden touch to his shoulder. Even after being back in Wonderland for a few months, he still has a little difficulty in strange social situations (and if he's honest, it's been a long time since anyone's patted his shoulder). Ultimately he settles on gently patting Peter's hand and offering an exceedingly awkward smile. He appreciates it, but he's really unsure how to react.

Besides, if Peter knew what he did, he probably wouldn't be trying to comfort him at all. He'd probably just be terrified of becoming him someday.]

Well, you won't know unless you read it, right? It sounds like you might actually have a shot if you do, if your friend's right about it.