Caroline bites her lip, thankful for Elena's grip, still trying to absorb all this strange newness that's happening so fast. The whole idea of time being that warped just doesn't compute very well for her right now.

"I guess, I mean anything's possible when there's weird magic involved." She squeezes Elena's hand, trying for a smile. "That's what a lot of this is, right? Magic, or whatever they want to call it. I'm pretty convinced it's all the same thing in the end."

Doesn't matter if it's a coven of witches or some crazy person with a few spells up their sleeve, it can wreck all sorts of havoc. Maybe even some children's book related havoc.

"Which birthday party was this, 'cause I don't even remember you having much of one this year." Yes, she's going to focus on that for a moment, because Caroline is all about a good party, even if the most recent one they had wasn't so hot.