who | elena gilbert & other bonnie bennett lovers.
where | the mansion.
when | march 12 - 14th. shoot me a pm if you want something, too!
rating | nothing scandalous.
summary | a bennett witch is gone, and those left behind will feel her loss deeply.
✧the story |

©
[closed] Broken hearts club | Billy & Peter
He knows how much Peter meant to Bonnie and he can't imagine Peter didn't feel the same. Billy knows what it's like to lose the person you love here, to have them suddenly disappear without a goodbye. Maybe he'll get to see Teddy again but the Bonnie Peter knew is gone. Even if she comes back she won't remember them. Billy also knows what that feels like.
So he's outside Peter's door a bottle of whiskey and a pint of ice cream in hand- he's not sure which Peter would rather. And he's knocking, hoping the other is there and he's not just standing in the hall with melting ice cream. ]
[closed] Broken hearts club
He steps over to the door and then opens it, blinking abruptly, when he realizes it's Billy there. A different sort of ache slams into his chest, because of course, he knows how important Bonnie was to Billy (how important Billy was to her). ]
Billy, hey. Uh. Come in.
Broken hearts club
Hey. I thought maybe you might want some company. You can totally kick me out if you don't, but I've found its better not to be alone when...well people we love go home.
Broken hearts club
Maybe it's part knowing how deeply Billy feels this loss too, and if Bonnie does come back, chances are high she won't remember them, either of them. ]
How've you been?
Broken hearts club
I've been better. How are you?
Broken hearts club
Kind of a mess. [ It's honest. He sinks down into a seat. ] I never expected it which I get was- I should have. She was here when I showed up. She found me, and- [ He shakes his head. Found him in more than one ways. ] You've been longer. You've probably been through this so many times.
Broken hearts club
[ He just nods at Peter's words. ] Bonnie is the eleventh person I've lost here. [ He's not sure if it's healthy to keep count of that but...oh well. ] It doesn't get easier, but I also wouldn't trade in ever knowing them. And that's what this is for.
[ He holds up the bottle that he brought with him. It's tradition. Drinking with someone after they lose someone else.
Broken hearts club
[ Peter says the words genuinely even as he winces, because this? This hurts like hell, and he doesn't know that he could go through it eleven times. He doesn't know how anyone goes through it so often and then gets up and stands up and still has the strength to reach out to another person. ]
I don't know how you do it. [ His voice aches, and then he shakes his head, clearing his throat of the- of the lump in it. He shakes his head after a moment. ] I don't drink, but I- I saw you brought ice cream.
Broken hearts club
I just...do it. Because what other choice do we have? I mean don't get me wrong, I've done my share of brooding and avoiding people here, but. It does start to get lonely. You're not alone here. [ He knows its good to hear that, he hopes it helps Peter. ]
Even if you don't wanna talk and you just want to play video games or eat ice cream. [ He hands Peter the pint and vanishes the bottle,
ice cream is just as good. ]
Broken hearts club
The last two times I've lost people back home, it's what I did. I pulled back. I hid away, because if you don't connect to people, you don't lose people. [ They can't abandon you. They can't die on you. But already things are different for him in Wonderland. He has made connections. There are people who care about him.
He's not a child who hasn't made many real friends yet. He's not the loner in high school who'd only just started to connect with one person. Peter reaches up, resting his hand against Billy's arm, as he tells him seriously: ]
You're not alone either.
Broken hearts club
But its awfully lonely, isn't it. I spent most of my time growing up alone, and I was fine with it. Until suddenly I wasn't alone anymore, now I don't really know how I did it. [ He never realized how important connecting with people was, until he had done it, and tried to push everyone away again.
He looks at Peter's hand before glancing back up at him and smiling. ] Thanks, Peter.
Broken hearts club
His chest sort of wants to pull itself to pieces but that's- that's pretty much its normal state lately. ] Thank you too for, y'know, the ice cream but mostly for stopping by.
Broken hearts club
[ All of that feels so long ago, and yet not long at all. He wants to shrug Peter's gratitude off, he doesn't feel particularly worthy of it, but he doesn't. He just nods. ]
Anytime. Really. I just wanted to make sure you were okay. [ And maybe take some of his loneliness away, if he could. ]
Broken hearts club
[ He was still getting used to doing the super powered thing at all back then. Peter sends him a little lopsided smile. ] Thanks. I'm doing okay. Mostly staying busy.
Broken hearts club
[ that was a loaded question. ] Sometimes yes, sometimes no. I mean when I first got them it was great, who doesn't want super powers? That's like the one thing ever kid wishes for. But the responsibility that comes with it? My powers were hard to control at first. I accidentally hurt people, those are things I regret. People died because we thought we could be heroes and we were just kids. We gave it up for a while, but. Well I have these powers and I can help people, how can I not use them for good? [ It was a debate he still got into with himself, or he did back home. Here it was different. ]
What about you? Are you grateful for them?
Broken hearts club
His hand clasps over Billy's arm.
He quiets as Billy describes everything. His gaze darts down to his hands, relating to what Billy's saying, because people have died because Peter went the route he went. His uncle. Gwen's father. Dr. Connor's life is ruined now. ]
I think I feel the same way. Complicated. People- Well, people died cause I got mine. I feel like I'm trying to make up for that loss and take on the responsibility so no one else has to die.
Broken hearts club
Peter isn't one of those people, he knew that, but having it confirmed, watching his anger on Billy's behalf, it changes the way Billy looks at him, just slightly. He holds him in a higher regard, he's a good friend and Billy is going to make sure that friendship lasts.
Peter's next words don't surprise Billy. Even if he hadn't know Peter in his world. ]
I feel like a lot of our stories are similar in that regard. Heroes, or people trying to be heroes. We all do seem to lose people, we all wonder if we're doing the right thing, is it worth it? For a while I didn't think it was. I think we will live our whole lives trying to make up for that loss, and all the losses to come. That's what separates us from the bad guys I guess.
Eventually we have to forgive ourselves, or at least someone wiser than me once told me that.
Broken hearts club
I don't think I've figured out how to do that part yet.
[ It's said softly as his gaze darts back up to Billy in the quiet, in the dark. He's grateful to not be alone in it now. There'd be another pile of papers, another forgotten project left behind.
It's hard for him to connect but not impossible if he opens up. ]
I'm glad you had some wise people in your life to help show you the way. God knows it's all- it's messy even with people.
Re: Broken hearts club
I'm still trying to figure out how to do that part too.
[ Easier said than done. He meets Peter's gaze and offers hi a smile.]
It's always messy, but it's the path we chose. People help though. It's easy to shut them out but, it's also easy to let them in. Surprisingly.
Broken hearts club
Think that's life. Figuring ourselves out over and over again.
[ Emotion lodges through his chest. ]
Still figuring out letting people in too. So y'know, forgive me if... I take awhile. [ Billy came to him and reached out to him, and Peter's not great at doing the same always. He pushes himself inward, puts up walls. Avoids. ]
Broken hearts club- wrap?